Trinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible Chapel
  • Jesus
  • About
    • Service Times & Location
    • Our Mission
    • Our Four Pillars
    • Our History
    • What We Believe
      • Our Doctrinal Statement
      • Specific Issues
        • Baptism and Communion
        • Church Government
        • Church Membership
        • Church Planting Philosophy
        • Church Structure
        • Counseling Philosophy
        • Creation, Evolution and God’s Sovereignty
        • Eternal Security of the Believer
        • Sufficiency of Scripture
        • Spiritual Warfare
        • The Trinity
        • Women in Ministry
        • Worship
    • Church Staff
    • Job Opportunities
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Project Rehoboth
      • Rehoboth Updates
    • King Alfred Academy
  • Connect
    • New Here?
      • Welcome to Trinity!
      • What Should I Expect?
      • How Can I Be Saved?
      • Get Baptized
      • University Bus Shuttle
    • Get Connected
      • Step 1: Connect
      • Step 2: Consider
      • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
      • Step 3: Commit to Serve
      • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
    • Resources
      • Weekly E-News
      • Events Calendar
      • Church App
      • Subscribe to Our Podcast
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Bible Reading Plans
      • Weddings
      • The Church At War Conference
      • Antichrist and His Ruin Documentary
  • Ministries
    • Trinity Kids
      • Parenting Resources
      • Web Protection Guide
      • Parenting Conference Audio
    • Trinity Youth
      • Youth Ministry Blog Posts
    • Small Groups
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Small Groups Blog Posts
      • Accountability Resources
    • University Bus Ministry
      • Adopt-A-Student Ministry
    • Worship Ministry
      • Family Worship
      • Weekend Song List
    • Sunday Support
    • Evangelism
      • Evangelism Videos
    • King Alfred Academy
    • Homeschool Collective
      • New to Homeschooling
      • Resources
      • Planning Pages
  • Sermons
    • Latest Sermon
    • View All by Date
    • View by Series
    • View by Preachers
    • View by Topics
    • View by Scriptures
    • Subscribe to Our Podcast
  • Blogs
    • The Pastor’s Blog
    • Trinity Ministry Blog
  • Give

The Pastor's Blog

By Jacob Reaume

A Response to TGC Canada’s Statement on Bruxyianity

By Jacob Reaume | November 14, 2018 | Leave a Comment |
Tagged: Bruxy Cavey, The Gospel Coalition

I have wished over and over to remove myself from this miserable mess.  The value of souls and the preservation of the Gospel for future generations propels me to reluctantly respond to The Gospel Coalition’s latest blog on the fiasco.  Their latest blog is an attempt to sum up their shared convictions on Paul Carter’s recent interviews with Bruxy Cavey.  If you’d like to get up to speed, you can read the history here.  In writing this response, I am firstly writing out of care for those within my own charge who read The Gospel Coalition, as I have been openly appreciative of much of their ministry.  I really dislike disagreeing so publicly with TGC, and it is something I am reticent to do.  I am also writing to those in the world-wide-web who will stumble upon this little blog.  I’ve heard stories of people—multiple people—who’ve been troubled over teachings at The Meeting House, but they, after reading the material from The Gospel Coalition, have decided things ain’t so bad under Cavey.  So they stay there and keep their families drinking in all the Bruxyianity.  I hope this will be helpful.

THE COMMENDATION TO CAVEY

The TGC article begins with some perceived strong points within The Meeting House’s ministry.  It reads:

Through the dialogue, we have come to appreciate certain aspects about the ministry being conducted at The Meeting House.  In particular, we point to their efforts to reach unchurched Canadians.  We agree that this is an urgent need in our generation, and we appreciate their attempts to reach younger Canadians in winsome ways.

I am quite happy to offer a commendation where one is due. Yet, is this really commendable?  The Meeting House is certainly employing an attractive tone to sell their ideas to people.  To say “we have come to appreciate” goes too far.  It assumes that they are actually attempting to reach people with something worthwhile.  I have no doubt that many within the organization believe they are attempting to reach people with the Gospel.  I am also confident that the pastors who work in the United Church of Canada believe they are reaching people with the Gospel, and so the same with those at your local Kingdom Hall.  The problem is they are using happy demeanors and sweet-hearted language to lead people over a cliff, and they call the 10,000 foot fall onto jagged rocks “Gospel.”  If TMH is offering the Gospel, then they deserve this commendation.  If they are offering poison, they deserve a severe dressing down.  If TGC is unsure which it is, TGC must avoid the commendations until they discern for themselves.

MORE THAN DOCTRINAL DISTINCTIVES

The language that TGC uses to describe their disagreement with Cavey’s teaching does not strike the appropriate level of urgency.  It reads:

While we appreciate these aspects of the Meeting House’s ministry, we nevertheless continue to hold to our distinctive beliefs and values as a community of reformed evangelical believers.

And also:

With all these matters in mind, our conclusion is that while we love and respect our neighbours at The Meeting House, we cannot in good conscience at this time endorse them nor follow the teaching of Bruxy Cavey on the above issues.

And this makes sense when we consider that The Meeting House itself would not be able to enroll their congregations in our church finder in good conscience because they can not affirm our foundation documents.  Both of us genuinely disagree with the other on important theological matters. (emphasis mine)

Using phraseology like “distinctive beliefs and values” and then later pitting the respective beliefs against each other as a matter of respectful disagreement in good conscience softens the level of urgency. For me, I “cannot in good conscience at this time endorse” the paedobaptism of Jonathan Edwards, but I must outright condemn the teachings of Bruxy Cavey.  To be clear Cavey has denied PSA, stated he’d like to convert people away from it, attacked the inerrancy of Scripture, and has also promoted a third way for homosexuals.  Yet, TGC’s phraseology so sweetens Cavey’s errors that an uninformed reader could readily assume this is just a minor discrepancy. If the statement were appropriately clear, I doubt Cavey would have been able to respond with this tweet:

If Bruxy Cavey were to spin just a sentence or two or three from the blog, that would be his fault.  But when he’s able to offer the entire article as evidence that TGC sees him—yes, him, the one who’s said he’d like to convert people away from PSA, who’s attacked the inerrancy of Scripture, who’s called the authority of Scripture unscriptural, and who’s opened up a third way for homosexuals—as a family member they’re sharpening, Cavey does not bear the fault alone.  A clear statement would not open itself up to this level of spin.  The mild choice of words does not suit the severity of the error.

BUT THIS IS NOT ABOUT WORDS

One of the ways Cavey has couched this again and again is by making this about words.  He alleges that we’re sounding alarms because he won’t say words like “inerrancy” which he has mockingly equated with “theological comfort food.”  If our concern is over words, it is more minor.  The major concern all along has been that Cavey attacks fundamental doctrines, the doctrine of biblical inerrancy being one of them.  Yet, TGC allows the issue to be less than it is:

Throughout this discussion, we have had a renewed opportunity to articulate our theological understanding, and we think there is deep wisdom in using certain time-tested language that was the subject of much conversation in the dialogue between Paul and Bruxy.

And:

We particularly treasure the word inerrancy and continue to affirm our commitment to our confessional position…

Further:

We hope and pray that the Meeting House will come to use the language of inerrancy to describe the Bible. It is a useful and clarifying term that will help ensure that the Word of God and not the opinions of people serves as the authority for what is trustworthy, beautiful, and true.

To be absolutely fair, TGC does not only affirm the words in question, but they go to great lengths in this article to affirm the specific doctrines.  We should be thankful for that.  Yet, while TGC affirms the doctrines, they cushion their disagreement with Cavey by making it about vocabulary and words.  They hope Cavey will affirm the same words.  How about calling Cavey to repent for opposing the faith that has come down to us on martyrs’ hands?  I have documented over and over that Cavey attacks concepts.  He opposes concepts.  He undermines actual doctrines.  He seeks by his own admission to convert people away from the core of the Gospel.  That TGC does not deal with this is a serious mistake.

THE ANABAPTIST CARD

The article highlights the divergent use of language between the evangelical and anabaptist traditions. They are two different streams of tradition, and thus it is only fair for us to expect that things are dealt with differently.  It would not be fair for evangelicals to only judge anabaptists by the standard of our own history.  Scripture is our final arbiter, not history.  That all sounds very nice, and I agree mostly.  The problem is twofold: First Cavey, anabaptist or not, teaches against actual Scripture, and second Bruxy Cavey does not find his theological origins in an anabaptist tradition.  His church might.  His denomination might.  But he does not.  In his own blog of July 4, 2018, Cavey says:

This was me when I first heard about the Anabaptist denomination I am now a part of – Be In Christ Canada (formerly, the Brethren In Christ).  I was an Evangelical with Reformed/Calvinist theology at the time I heard about the BIC.

At one point Bruxy Cavey was an Evangelical with Reformed/Calvinist theology.  He’s moved away from it.  The trajectory of Bruxy Cavey has been away from orthodoxy, not toward it.  That TGC has not pointed this out is a major pitfall in their assessment.  Cavey has moved away from orthodoxy, and he’s taken people with him.

CONCLUSION

Had The Gospel Coalition website not already offered “Props to Bruxy Cavey” and had it not been a platform for Bruxy Cavey to spin his teaching and had it not already stated definitively, “Bruxy Cavey is not a heretic.  He’s an Anabaptist,” I think I could have been more positive about this.  But I appraise it all in context of TGC’s large swath of recorded material on an influential pastor who has attacked the inerrancy of Scripture, has expressed desire to convert people away from PSA, and has opened up a third way for homosexuals.

With that, I close with what disquiets me most.  It is much more than a concern over theological phraseology and doctrinal precision, as much as I’m burdened by all that.  What disquiets me most is a great source of personal grief, and that personal grief is pastoral grief specifically.  I am disheartened by the dearth of urgent expressions of pastoral alarm for those who’ve been taken captive by Bruxyianity.  There are people who actually believe what Bruxy Cavey says about the Bible, about the atonement, and about all the other nonsense he teaches.  While TGC has attempted to model charity and civility, they have lacked the basic pathos and clarity needed to charitably warn the innocent onlookers that this is something more than a writing assignment.  These are not fussy little spats over verbiage and doctrinal precision.  We are not debating how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.  We’re dealing with an outright assault on the inerrancy of Scripture, not to mention the gutting of the Gospel of Jesus Christ.  Our Lord Jesus Christ has been maligned by one of Canada’s most popular pastors, and many call that maligning “Gospel.”  Souls are in danger, folks, and eternity is real.


SHARE


Comments

Related Posts

  • The Rainbow Flag, Local Council, and Elmira’s Streets

    By Jacob Reaume | August 23, 2022

    Elmira is Ontario’s latest community to look at painting a trendy rainbow on one of it’s streets.  Apparently, the Canadian Association of Mental Health has requested that the municipality paint one on a local crosswalk as a show of support for the LGBTQS2+ community.  Those letters — LGBTQS2+ — are likely the latest alpha-numeric codeRead more

  • A Gay Bar with Free Math Lessons

    By Jacob Reaume | June 15, 2022

    I have been advising parents to pull their children from public schools for several years.  The primary objective of education should be to foster Christian virtue in the hearts of children.  Apparently this view was once shared by the majority of Ontarians to the point that they had it enshrined in law.  Section 264.1.c ofRead more

  • Protect Your Children from Public School

    By Jacob Reaume | June 9, 2022

    A few months ago, I reported (here) of a Waterloo Region public school teacher who the WRDSB chair censored at a board meeting.  Her offence?  She questioned whether school officials should be teaching children that hormone blockers are a good idea.  She did so while quoting a public school library book that presented hormone blockersRead more

  • Wisdom in Evangelizing Your Children

    By Jacob Reaume | May 17, 2022

    The following is adapted from a short sermon I gave at a child-dedication service on Mother’s Day. Introduction Many think that there is a recipe to get your children into the Kingdom of God.  “Maybe if I just protect them enough from the world they will be good,” some may reason. The problem is thatRead more

  • John Bunyan Opposed Church Attendance Limits

    By Jacob Reaume | May 12, 2022

    Just over a year ago, the Province of Ontario seized our church building and charged me, along with all our elders, with contempt of court for the second time.  The Province, claiming to be acting in the public good, had set limits on church attendance, and we had no regard for them.  We, ourselves claimingRead more

Newer PostOlder Post

Top 5 Trending

  • What does “makes her commit adultery” mean? (Matt. 5:32)

    October 25, 2018
  • Forbidden Love – The Sons of God and the Daughters of Man, Part 2: The Argument

    September 9, 2014
  • Yes, Bruxy Cavey Is A False Teacher

    July 11, 2018
  • A Gay Bar with Free Math Lessons

    June 15, 2022
  • The Bloodlines of Jesus

    October 13, 2014

Latest Posts

  • The Rainbow Flag, Local Council, and Elmira’s Streets

    August 23, 2022
  • A Gay Bar with Free Math Lessons

    June 15, 2022
  • Protect Your Children from Public School

    June 9, 2022
  • Wisdom in Evangelizing Your Children

    May 17, 2022
  • John Bunyan Opposed Church Attendance Limits

    May 12, 2022

About the Author

Jacob Reaume

Born and raised in Guelph, Jacob holds a Master of Divinity from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Kentucky. He became pastor of Trinity Bible Chapel in August, 2009. Jacob is married to his high school sweetheart, Joanna, and together they have six children.

CHURCH LOCATION
Address:    1373 Lobsinger Line
Waterloo, ON, N2J 4G8

Phone: 519-658-6333
Email: info@trinitybiblechapel.ca

NEW HERE?

  • Service Times & Location
  • Welcome to Trinity!
  • What Should I Expect?
  • How Can I Be Saved?
  • University Bus Shuttle
  • Our Mission
  • Our Doctrinal Statement

OUR MINISTRIES

  • Trinity Kids
  • Trinity Youth
  • Small Groups
  • University Bus Ministry
  • Worship Ministry
  • Sunday Support
  • Evangelism

GET CONNECTED

  • Step 1: Connect
  • Step 2: Consider
  • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
  • Step 3: Commit to Serve
  • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
  • Get Baptized
  • Events Calendar
Trinity Bible Chapel on Rumble
Copyright © 2022 Trinity Bible Chapel
  • Jesus
  • About
    • Service Times & Location
    • Our Mission
    • Our Four Pillars
    • Our History
    • What We Believe
      • Our Doctrinal Statement
      • Specific Issues
        • Baptism and Communion
        • Church Government
        • Church Membership
        • Church Planting Philosophy
        • Church Structure
        • Counseling Philosophy
        • Creation, Evolution and God’s Sovereignty
        • Eternal Security of the Believer
        • Sufficiency of Scripture
        • Spiritual Warfare
        • The Trinity
        • Women in Ministry
        • Worship
    • Church Staff
    • Job Opportunities
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Project Rehoboth
      • Rehoboth Updates
    • King Alfred Academy
  • Connect
    • New Here?
      • Welcome to Trinity!
      • What Should I Expect?
      • How Can I Be Saved?
      • Get Baptized
      • University Bus Shuttle
    • Get Connected
      • Step 1: Connect
      • Step 2: Consider
      • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
      • Step 3: Commit to Serve
      • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
    • Resources
      • Weekly E-News
      • Events Calendar
      • Church App
      • Subscribe to Our Podcast
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Bible Reading Plans
      • Weddings
      • The Church At War Conference
      • Antichrist and His Ruin Documentary
  • Ministries
    • Trinity Kids
      • Parenting Resources
      • Web Protection Guide
      • Parenting Conference Audio
    • Trinity Youth
      • Youth Ministry Blog Posts
    • Small Groups
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Small Groups Blog Posts
      • Accountability Resources
    • University Bus Ministry
      • Adopt-A-Student Ministry
    • Worship Ministry
      • Family Worship
      • Weekend Song List
    • Sunday Support
    • Evangelism
      • Evangelism Videos
    • King Alfred Academy
    • Homeschool Collective
      • New to Homeschooling
      • Resources
      • Planning Pages
  • Sermons
    • Latest Sermon
    • View All by Date
    • View by Series
    • View by Preachers
    • View by Topics
    • View by Scriptures
    • Subscribe to Our Podcast
  • Blogs
    • The Pastor’s Blog
    • Trinity Ministry Blog
  • Give
Trinity Bible Chapel