Trinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible Chapel
  • Jesus
  • About
    • Service Times & Location
    • Our Mission
    • Our Four Pillars
    • Our History
    • What We Believe
      • Our Doctrinal Statement
      • Specific Issues
        • Baptism and Communion
        • Church Government
        • Church Membership
        • Church Planting Philosophy
        • Church Structure
        • Counseling Philosophy
        • Creation, Evolution and God’s Sovereignty
        • Eternal Security of the Believer
        • Sufficiency of Scripture
        • Spiritual Warfare
        • The Trinity
        • Women in Ministry
        • Worship
    • Church Staff
    • Job Opportunities
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Project Rehoboth
      • Rehoboth Updates
    • King Alfred Academy
  • Connect
    • New Here?
      • Welcome to Trinity!
      • What Should I Expect?
      • How Can I Be Saved?
      • Get Baptized
      • University Bus Shuttle
    • Get Connected
      • Step 1: Connect
      • Step 2: Consider
      • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
      • Step 3: Commit to Serve
      • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
    • Resources
      • Weekly E-News
      • Events Calendar
      • Church App
      • Subscribe to Our Podcast
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Bible Reading Plans
      • Weddings
      • The Church At War Conference
      • Antichrist and His Ruin Documentary
  • Ministries
    • Trinity Kids
      • Parenting Resources
      • Web Protection Guide
      • Parenting Conference Audio
    • Trinity Youth
      • Youth Ministry Blog Posts
    • Small Groups
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Small Groups Blog Posts
      • Accountability Resources
    • University Bus Ministry
      • Adopt-A-Student Ministry
    • Worship Ministry
      • Family Worship
      • Weekend Song List
    • Sunday Support
    • Evangelism
      • Evangelism Videos
    • King Alfred Academy
    • Homeschool Collective
      • New to Homeschooling
      • Resources
      • Planning Pages
  • Sermons
    • Latest Sermon
    • View All by Date
    • View by Series
    • View by Preachers
    • View by Topics
    • View by Scriptures
    • Subscribe to Our Podcast
  • Blogs
    • The Pastor’s Blog
    • Trinity Ministry Blog
  • Give

The Pastor's Blog

By Jacob Reaume

Defining the Evangelical Fault Line: The Bruxy Cavey Controversy

By Jacob Reaume | July 17, 2018 | Leave a Comment |
Tagged: Bruxy Cavey

The controversy surrounding Bruxy Cavey is, in my opinion, the most significant theological controversy Canadian Evangelicals have faced in 70 years—at least since the fundamentalist/modernist controversy. In writing about this once again, I can empathize with Jude who said he would rather write about “our common salvation,” but “found it necessary to write appealing to you to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints. For certain people have crept in unnoticed…” (Jude 1:2-3). There are more fragrantly aromatic colognes than eau-de-le-gars-qui-a-réprimendé-bruxy-cavey. But, as I learned at the rink growing up, you don’t get to pick your spots. Sometimes you just end up being bashed against the boards in the corner while chasing the puck, even if you’d rather be the finesse guy gracefully twirling around the defencemen to deke out the goalie for the game winner in overtime. It is what it is.

Thank God it’s not a terribly lonely corner over here. Pastor Paul Carter blogged about this last week, as did Wyatt Graham. A few weeks ago the guys a the Rebel Alliance Podcast made their position clear. And Tim Challies has been kind enough to promote this material too. And, we need not forget about my old pal Eric Schneider who’s, well, been quite helpful. We should also send some love to the guys over at Tyndale University’s philosophy department too. Did I mention that our friends at Tyndale philosophy are Arminians as best as I can tell? I only throw that in because Cavey and his people have wrongfully blamed all this on Calvinists. As it turns out, Arminians and Calvinists can agree on a lot of important things, even if one of those things is that Bruxy Cavey should be refuted. Alas, the Lord is raising up good men.

Moving on to one of the reasons I believe this is so important: Canadian Evangelicals are now being forced to define who we are. This is a natural process that the Church must go through at least every generation or so, and we happen to be going through it right now. We didn’t choose it, but we are now in it. Where you land on this will make history whether you like it or not, even if you claim neutrality. In AD 597 Augustine of Canterbury evangelized the Anglo-Saxons, and since then successive generations of English speaking Christians have had to define heresy, fight heresy, and by so doing they have preserved the truth right up until this point right here. This is our hour, and we cannot hide from it.

So, what is at stake? I submit that the Gospel of Jesus Christ is on the line. That’s why I’m making such a big deal about it. But more specifically I believe we are seeing three foundational issues emerge: (1) Scripture, (2) the atonement, and (3) sexual ethics. Interestingly enough, Bruxy Cavey seems to believe the same. This controversy is now so serious that he addressed it specifically at the start of his sermon on Sunday. He did acknowledge those issues, but I should note that he framed them in a very unhelpful way. There is a fault line emerging. With that I’ll touch on each point specifically.

The Scriptures

Has God spoken, and if He has what has He said? I submit that He has spoken on the pages of Holy Scripture, and because of that we have no higher authority to which we can appeal than Scripture. Cavey, on the other hand, has called the authority of Scripture “unscriptural,” “weird,” and “made up.” While, he claims to believe Jesus is his highest authority, we are left asking, “Which Jesus?” It’s absolute nonsense to divide Christ’s authority from the authority of Scripture, as Cavey is doing. If the Bible is the written Word of God, and if Jesus is God, then we can be assured that the Scriptures are the written Word of Jesus. So to pontificate—pontificate is great word here— about Jesus outside the Scriptures is bananas. It’s like dividing the authority of the King from His edict, or the authority of the boss from his instructions, or the authority of the government from its laws. Yes, it’s bananas. And it leads to trouble, big time. Do Canadian evangelicals believe the Bible is the inerrant authoritative Word of God, and do we believe it enough to take a stand right here? This is the first issue.

The Atonement

My sense is that the previous issue is likely a lot easier for Evangelicals to stand for then this one. I say that because of interactions I’ve had with other brothers who are wondering if I’m making too much of an issue over penal substitutionary atonement. To be clear, I am not saying that confusion over the atonement or a lack of understanding about the atonement is tantamount to apostasy. No, I’m not saying that. I am saying that an informed outright denial of penal substitutionary atonement is a denial of the Gospel. And I am saying that one who’d like to convert people away from penal substitutionary atonement is a predatory wolf, not a brother. Bruxy Cavey has denied it outright and has boasted that he’d like to convert people away from it. Also, I am not saying that penal subsitutionary atonement is all there is to the Gospel. But I am saying that without it we do not have a Gospel. I completely understand why some brothers are taking some time to process this, but I do believe they will land at the right place in due-time. Yesterday, I had a conversation with a respected seminary professor about this. His comment to me was that this issue is now forcing evangelicals to think about atonement, which we both agree is positive because without penal substitutionary atonement we have no Gospel. My sense is we likely haven’t had to think about it in this much detail—at least in Canada—for, well, maybe 70 years. A new generation has the opportunity to think this through and take up the torch of our fore bearers. It will likely just take some time to process it all. But a pastor who is open to attacks on the atonement now, even if he holds to PSA himself, is normalizing those attacks and could be preparing the way for his church to deny PSA in the next generation.

Sexual Ethics

Bruxy Cavey has compromised the biblical teaching on homosexuality. We should not be surprised, as he’s only going along with the zeitgeist. But now we must decide where we stand. And it’s not the first time we’ve had to do that either. Paul wrote his letter to the Romans (specifically Romans 1) to a church in the seat of the Empire which was ruled by a homosexual emperor. Paul was clear where he stood. He also wrote 1 Corinthians (specifically 1 Corinthians 6:9) to a church in what was considered likely the most licentious city in the Empire. He was clear where he stood. St. Peter Damian (1007-1072 AD) found himself surrounded by a church compromised by sexual immorality, and he wrote The Book of Gomorrah as a rebuke to the loose sexual morals of the ecclesiastical elites. When the culture develops loose morals, the temptation is to do the same. But the true Church has always stood against the zeitgeist. In these days we are deciding whether the next generation in our churches will resemble the whore of Babylon that St. Peter Damian opposed or whether they will live in the holiness without which they cannot be saved. The trajectory of Bruxy Cavey is now obvious, and so should the trajectory of all our churches be, one way or another. From this question we cannot hide. To abandon a Scriptural view of sexuality is to abandon the Gospel of Jesus Christ. Silence on this point will only allow the culture to disciple our churches.

Conclusion

Thus have the issues been framed: (1) Scripture, (2) the atonement, and (3), sexual ethics. These are the issues of our generation, and we did not pick the issues any more than we picked the generation. We don’t get to pick our spots. We simply stand where God has placed us, and if we stand upon that Rock we will stand victoriously. And against us the gates of hell will not prevail.


SHARE


Comments

Related Posts

  • The Meaning of “Sabbath” in Colossians 2:16

    By Jacob Reaume | June 28, 2023

    The 4th Commandment, the one that pertains to the Sabbath, is the most contested of the Ten Commandments.  In fact it’s the only commandment that is actually contested among Christians who hold to an orthodox view of Scripture.  A number argue that the requirement of Sabbath is not for today.  It was for the OldRead more

  • The Discontentment Of Pride

    By Jacob Reaume | June 7, 2023

    The homosexual movement cannot be satisfied.  A short few years ago, they just wanted the right to be “married”.  So, overhauling millennia of tradition, the government tried to reinvent marriage for them. Just for them.  They overthrew a cornerstone of civilization.  And that wasn’t enough.  It was once “GLB.”  Then “LGB.”  Then “LGBT.”  “LGBTQ.”  IRead more

  • Is A Woman’s Hair The Headcovering of 1 Cor. 11?

    By Jacob Reaume | May 24, 2023

    Last week, I reviewed Dale Partridge’s book, A Covering for Glory (see here).  The book makes the case for women wearing headcoverings during worship services, as well as for men not wearing headcoverings during worship services.  I offered a favourable review, as I wholly support his position.  In 2017, I preached from 1 Corinthians 11:2-16Read more

  • Book Review: A Cover for Glory, by Dale Partridge

    By Jacob Reaume | May 16, 2023

    Dale Partridge wrote A Cover for Glory, which Relearn Press published just recently in 2023.  Partridge is the pastor of King’s Way Bible Church in Prescott, Arizona, and he leads several other ministries, including Reformation Seminary.  The book is an exegetical study of 1 Corinthians 11:2-16, which is the biblical passage that instructs women toRead more

  • John Bunyan, Josh Buice, and Christian Nationalism

    By Jacob Reaume | April 25, 2023

    Christian Nationalism is all the chatter, occupying headspace for anyone who cares to listen.  The secular establishment has been given over to unthinkable manifold depravities, and some folks are looking for a better foundation than the poisoned fluidity of secularism.  As fluid and gender-fluid as secularism might be, the definition of Christian Nationalism might beRead more

Newer PostOlder Post

Top 5 Trending

  • What does “makes her commit adultery” mean? (Matt. 5:32)

    October 25, 2018
  • Is A Woman’s Hair The Headcovering of 1 Cor. 11?

    May 24, 2023
  • Forbidden Love – The Sons of God and the Daughters of Man, Part 2: The Argument

    September 9, 2014
  • The Bloodlines of Jesus

    October 13, 2014
  • The Meaning of “Sabbath” in Colossians 2:16

    June 28, 2023

Latest Posts

  • The Meaning of “Sabbath” in Colossians 2:16

    June 28, 2023
  • The Discontentment Of Pride

    June 7, 2023
  • Is A Woman’s Hair The Headcovering of 1 Cor. 11?

    May 24, 2023
  • Book Review: A Cover for Glory, by Dale Partridge

    May 16, 2023
  • John Bunyan, Josh Buice, and Christian Nationalism

    April 25, 2023

About the Author

Jacob Reaume

Born and raised in Guelph, Jacob holds a Master of Divinity from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Kentucky. He became pastor of Trinity Bible Chapel in August, 2009. Jacob is married to his high school sweetheart, Joanna, and together they have six children.

CHURCH LOCATION
Address:    1373 Lobsinger Line
Waterloo, ON, N2J 4G8

Phone: 519-658-6333
Email: info@trinitybiblechapel.ca

NEW HERE?

  • Service Times & Location
  • Welcome to Trinity!
  • What Should I Expect?
  • How Can I Be Saved?
  • University Bus Shuttle
  • Our Mission
  • Our Doctrinal Statement

OUR MINISTRIES

  • Trinity Kids
  • Trinity Youth
  • Small Groups
  • University Bus Ministry
  • Worship Ministry
  • Sunday Support
  • Evangelism

GET CONNECTED

  • Step 1: Connect
  • Step 2: Consider
  • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
  • Step 3: Commit to Serve
  • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
  • Get Baptized
  • Events Calendar
Trinity Bible Chapel on Rumble
Copyright © 2022 Trinity Bible Chapel
  • Jesus
  • About
    • Service Times & Location
    • Our Mission
    • Our Four Pillars
    • Our History
    • What We Believe
      • Our Doctrinal Statement
      • Specific Issues
        • Baptism and Communion
        • Church Government
        • Church Membership
        • Church Planting Philosophy
        • Church Structure
        • Counseling Philosophy
        • Creation, Evolution and God’s Sovereignty
        • Eternal Security of the Believer
        • Sufficiency of Scripture
        • Spiritual Warfare
        • The Trinity
        • Women in Ministry
        • Worship
    • Church Staff
    • Job Opportunities
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Project Rehoboth
      • Rehoboth Updates
    • King Alfred Academy
  • Connect
    • New Here?
      • Welcome to Trinity!
      • What Should I Expect?
      • How Can I Be Saved?
      • Get Baptized
      • University Bus Shuttle
    • Get Connected
      • Step 1: Connect
      • Step 2: Consider
      • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
      • Step 3: Commit to Serve
      • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
    • Resources
      • Weekly E-News
      • Events Calendar
      • Church App
      • Subscribe to Our Podcast
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Bible Reading Plans
      • Weddings
      • The Church At War Conference
      • Antichrist and His Ruin Documentary
  • Ministries
    • Trinity Kids
      • Parenting Resources
      • Web Protection Guide
      • Parenting Conference Audio
    • Trinity Youth
      • Youth Ministry Blog Posts
    • Small Groups
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Small Groups Blog Posts
      • Accountability Resources
    • University Bus Ministry
      • Adopt-A-Student Ministry
    • Worship Ministry
      • Family Worship
      • Weekend Song List
    • Sunday Support
    • Evangelism
      • Evangelism Videos
    • King Alfred Academy
    • Homeschool Collective
      • New to Homeschooling
      • Resources
      • Planning Pages
  • Sermons
    • Latest Sermon
    • View All by Date
    • View by Series
    • View by Preachers
    • View by Topics
    • View by Scriptures
    • Subscribe to Our Podcast
  • Blogs
    • The Pastor’s Blog
    • Trinity Ministry Blog
  • Give
Trinity Bible Chapel