Trinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible ChapelTrinity Bible Chapel
  • Jesus
  • About
    • Service Times & Location
    • Our Mission
    • Our Four Pillars
    • Our History
    • What We Believe
      • Our Doctrinal Statement
      • London Baptist Confession of 1689
      • Specific Issues
        • Baptism and Communion
        • Church Government
        • Church Membership
        • Church Planting Philosophy
        • Church Structure
        • Counseling Philosophy
        • Creation, Evolution and God’s Sovereignty
        • Eternal Security of the Believer
        • Sufficiency of Scripture
        • Spiritual Warfare
        • The Trinity
        • Women in Ministry
        • Worship
    • Church Staff
    • Job Opportunities
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • Connect
    • New Here?
      • What Should I Expect?
      • How Can I Be Saved?
      • Get Baptized
      • University Bus Shuttle
    • Get Connected
      • Step 1: Connect
      • Step 2: Consider
      • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
      • Step 3: Commit to Serve
      • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
    • Resources
      • Weekly E-News
      • Events Calendar
      • Church App
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Bible Reading Plans
      • Resources for Original Hymn/Psalm Tunes
      • Weddings
  • Ministries
    • Trinity Kids
      • Parenting Resources
      • Web Protection Guide
      • Parenting Conference Audio
    • Trinity Youth
      • Youth Ministry Blog Posts
    • Small Groups
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Small Groups Blog Posts
      • Accountability Resources
    • University Bus Ministry
      • Adopt-A-Student Ministry
    • Worship Ministry
      • Family Worship
      • Weekend Song List
      • Resources for Original Hymn/Psalm Tunes
    • Sunday Support
    • Evangelism
      • Evangelism Videos
    • Global Missions
      • Tanzania
        • Global Missions Blog
      • Ethnos
    • King Alfred Academy
    • Homeschool Collective
      • New to Homeschooling
      • Resources
      • Planning Pages
    • Cromwell Hall
    • Asser Press
  • Sermons
    • Latest Sermon
    • View All by Date
    • View by Series
    • View by Preachers
    • View by Topics
    • View by Scriptures
    • Past Conference Messages
      • The Presence of Christ Conference (2024)
      • The Church At War Conference (2022)
    • Subscribe to Our Podcast
  • Blogs
    • The Pastor’s Blog
    • Trinity Ministry Blog
  • Give

Trinity Ministry Blog

Equipping the Saints

Critics of Penal Substitution Can’t Have It Both Ways

By Will Schuurman | September 12, 2018 | Leave a Comment |
Tagged: penal substitution, penal substitutionary atonement, theology

The doctrine of penal substitutionary atonement (PSA) has been at the center of a recent theological controversy here in Ontario. Throughout church history, Christians have rightly understood this doctrine to be central to Christ’s cross-work. Since the 19th century, however, in conjunction with the rise of liberalism, this doctrine has periodically found itself in the theological crosshairs of liberal scholars and pastors. Consequently, over the past two centuries, faithful ministers of the gospel have had to defend this doctrine and argue for its centrality to the Christian faith. Men such as Charles Spurgeon, Martin Lloyd-Jones, J.I. Packer, John Stott, John Piper, John MacArthur, and Albert Mohler have all argued that penal substitution is central to the Christian gospel and to deny it is to deny the gospel. My pastor is in agreement with them and has similarly argued that a denial of penal substitution is a denial of the very gospel itself. Opponents of penal substitution don’t like that assertion. They usually respond by explaining that penal substitution is just one theory of the atonement and that there are other theories that Christians can choose from. Although we may have differing beliefs on what Christ accomplished for us on the cross, we still believe the same gospel…or so they say.

There are several problems with that argument. My pastor has written about some of them here and here. For the purposes of this blog, I want to focus in on the double standard exhibited by many opponents of penal substitution. The double standard is as follows: (1) when opponents of PSA are on the offensive, they argue that the God of PSA is a different deity than the ‘god’ they believe in whereas (2) when they’re on the defensive, they argue that we all believe the same gospel even though our understanding of the atonement differs. They want to have it both ways. They want to paint proponents of PSA as those who believe in a different deity but they don’t want to live with the implications of such an assertion.

I have heard opponents of penal substitution regularly use terms like “monster”, “barbaric”, “blood-thirsty”, “child-abusing”, “vampire”, and even “a pagan deity” when referring to the God of PSA. This kind of rhetoric is not only offensive and blasphemous, it also intentionally implies a belief in a different deity. According to critics of PSA that portray God in these terms, we believe in different gods. This begs the question: If we worship different gods, then don’t we also believe different gospels? You cannot believe in different gods and yet ascribe to the same gospel. Opponents of PSA that use this kind of rhetoric can’t have it both ways.

In the book, Pierced For Our Transgressions, the authors pick up on this inconsistency:

It seems that opponents of penal substitution are agreed on the magnitude of the issue. They contend that penal substitution is an unbiblical view of the cross without support in the historic church. They claim that penal substitution undermines the doctrine of the Trinity, without which Christianity would not be Christianity at all. More than that, they insist that penal substitution portrays God as an unjust tyrant, a vindictive child abuser, and a hypocrite who pays no regard to Jesus’ foundational teaching about love…

These charges are extremely serious. We cannot pretend that critics of penal substitution are raising a minor point of dispute: they are accusing us of propagating a theological novelty, imposing our twisted modern world views on God’s holy word, unwittingly encouraging and justifying sadistic acts of violence, and worshipping a malevolent, hypocritical deity who bears no resemblance whatsoever to the loving God of the Bible. Disagreements over penal substitution are fundamental; they cannot be ignored…If those who impugn penal substitution refuse to reconsider their position, there comes a time when we have no alternative but to part company. For the critics are right in this: differences over penal substitution ultimately lead us to worship a different God and to believe a different gospel.[1]

Thus, the doctrine of penal substitution is a dividing line. It’s not a dividing line between Reformed Christians and Anabaptist Christians. It’s not a dividing line between Calvinists and Arminians. It’s a dividing line between the true gospel and a false gospel. Critics of penal substitution can’t claim the God of PSA is a “pagan deity” and then act surprised when proponents of PSA conclude we believe different gospels. That’s a double standard. If we believe in different gods, then we believe different gospels.

 

_________________________

[1] Jeffrey, Ovey, & Sach. Pierced for Our Transgressions, p216-217.


SHARE


Comments

Related Posts

  • What is Successful Evangelism?

    By Zach Smith | May 2, 2025

    What is Successful Evangelism? How do we know if our evangelism is effective? If it has been successful? If God is pleased with our service? These are questions that I have frequently been asked since I began as a lay leader in Trinity’s evangelism ministry in 2019. Often, though not always, the people who areRead more

  • An Arrangement for Singing the Doxology in Three Parts

    By John Maggs | October 3, 2024

    This Sunday evening we are planning to learn to sing an arrangement of the Doxology in three parts. The rationale for this particular arrangement, versus the many possible good arrangements, will be explained Sunday evening. Some of you may notice that the arrangement is not SATB (Soprano, Alto, Tenor, Bass…like a hymnal). This is intentional,Read more

  • How Should I Educate My Child(ren)?

    By Randy Frey | May 26, 2023

    This blog post was co-authored by Pastor of Christian Education Randy Frey and Trinity Homeschool Collective leadership team member Bridgett Maggs. Introduction This time of year, many families are making important decisions about how their children will be educated in the upcoming year. Within the context of our church family, we are thankful to haveRead more

  • Isaac Watts and The Ruin of Antichrist

    By John Maggs | September 19, 2022

    The Church at War conference coming up in November which will see the premier of the Antichrist and His Ruin documentary as well as an exceptional line-up of speakers and preachers. (For more information about the conference, please see here. For the documentary, here). The theme of Antichrist can evoke different reactions, perhaps because ofRead more

  • Is the Church at War?

    By Will Schuurman | August 31, 2022

    In November of this year there will be a conference hosted at our church titled, “The Church At War Conference.” From what we have seen and heard so far, it sounds like there is widespread interest in this conference, for which we are thankful. However, I have seen at least one comment opposing the titleRead more

Newer PostOlder Post

Latest Posts

  • What is Successful Evangelism?

    May 2, 2025
  • An Arrangement for Singing the Doxology in Three Parts

    October 3, 2024
  • How Should I Educate My Child(ren)?

    May 26, 2023
  • Isaac Watts and The Ruin of Antichrist

    September 19, 2022
  • Is the Church at War?

    August 31, 2022

Contributors

Will Schuurman

Associate Pastor

Randy Frey

Pastor of Christian Education

John Maggs

Director of Creative Ministries

CHURCH LOCATION
Address:    1373 Lobsinger Line
Waterloo, ON, N2J 4G8

Phone: 519-658-6333
Email: info@trinitybiblechapel.ca

NEW HERE?

  • Service Times & Location
  • What Should I Expect?
  • How Can I Be Saved?
  • University Bus Shuttle
  • Our Mission
  • Our Doctrinal Statement
  • Sermons

OUR MINISTRIES

  • Trinity Kids
  • Trinity Youth
  • Small Groups
  • University Bus Ministry
  • Worship Ministry
  • Sunday Support
  • Evangelism

GET CONNECTED

  • Step 1: Connect
  • Step 2: Consider
  • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
  • Step 3: Commit to Serve
  • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
  • Get Baptized
  • Events Calendar
Trinity Bible Chapel on Rumble
Copyright © 2025 Trinity Bible Chapel
  • Jesus
  • About
    • Service Times & Location
    • Our Mission
    • Our Four Pillars
    • Our History
    • What We Believe
      • Our Doctrinal Statement
      • London Baptist Confession of 1689
      • Specific Issues
        • Baptism and Communion
        • Church Government
        • Church Membership
        • Church Planting Philosophy
        • Church Structure
        • Counseling Philosophy
        • Creation, Evolution and God’s Sovereignty
        • Eternal Security of the Believer
        • Sufficiency of Scripture
        • Spiritual Warfare
        • The Trinity
        • Women in Ministry
        • Worship
    • Church Staff
    • Job Opportunities
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
  • Connect
    • New Here?
      • What Should I Expect?
      • How Can I Be Saved?
      • Get Baptized
      • University Bus Shuttle
    • Get Connected
      • Step 1: Connect
      • Step 2: Consider
      • Step 3: Commit to a Small Group
      • Step 3: Commit to Serve
      • Step 4: Covenant in Membership
    • Resources
      • Weekly E-News
      • Events Calendar
      • Church App
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Bible Reading Plans
      • Resources for Original Hymn/Psalm Tunes
      • Weddings
  • Ministries
    • Trinity Kids
      • Parenting Resources
      • Web Protection Guide
      • Parenting Conference Audio
    • Trinity Youth
      • Youth Ministry Blog Posts
    • Small Groups
      • Pulpit Curriculum
      • Small Groups Blog Posts
      • Accountability Resources
    • University Bus Ministry
      • Adopt-A-Student Ministry
    • Worship Ministry
      • Family Worship
      • Weekend Song List
      • Resources for Original Hymn/Psalm Tunes
    • Sunday Support
    • Evangelism
      • Evangelism Videos
    • Global Missions
      • Tanzania
        • Global Missions Blog
      • Ethnos
    • King Alfred Academy
    • Homeschool Collective
      • New to Homeschooling
      • Resources
      • Planning Pages
    • Cromwell Hall
    • Asser Press
  • Sermons
    • Latest Sermon
    • View All by Date
    • View by Series
    • View by Preachers
    • View by Topics
    • View by Scriptures
    • Past Conference Messages
      • The Presence of Christ Conference (2024)
      • The Church At War Conference (2022)
    • Subscribe to Our Podcast
  • Blogs
    • The Pastor’s Blog
    • Trinity Ministry Blog
  • Give
Trinity Bible Chapel